Gerrard for the fact he's carried a team for nearly 10 years single handedly.
Plus Gerrard is the much more versatile player, can do what Lamps and Carrick specialize in, not to the same ability of course but he could do it competently.
Lampard
Carrick
Gerrard
Gerrard is most overated englishman of all time, you can't win a league with superman wannabes
Gerrard for the fact he's carried a team for nearly 10 years single handedly.
Plus Gerrard is the much more versatile player, can do what Lamps and Carrick specialize in, not to the same ability of course but he could do it competently.
Would have liked to see all three in a different country
One of the biggest myths ever
"Gerrard carried Liverpool"
I cannot remember any big games he single handedly won for the team
Feel free to name one
/
Lampard I cannot rate as a top midfielder when his biggest asset is goalscoring
Carrick I like but he isn't that guy Clive Tydsley thinks he is
The amount of times I have heard the phrase "Carrick should be dominating this game and if there is one person on this pitch(bear in mind a big European game is going on) who can stamp his authority on a game like this it's Michael Carrick"
The game always seems to pass him by
Gerrard aka superman
He tries to be the hero and his international career is a failure
Everyone has blamed the managers moving him around in the past but
In the last two major tournaments he has played in CM
His legs have gone and is finished
He was chasing shadows@The Euros
The only thing which is saving him the fact he has a dead ball delivery in his locker.
/
I can't rate pick one over the other out of this three mentioned but if it was Scholes being discussed then it will be a different matter altogether
FA Cup Final 06
Never
West Ham dominated the 1st half
Liverpool were literally playing with ten men
Gerrard was hobbling/passenger
He scored that goal in extra time to deny West Ham the trophy
That's not carrying a team
Or single handedly
Like I said man was a passenger
It was another game which passed him by
Scored two and set up the other
That's not carrying a team
That's just stats
Watch a re run of the game
Messi's record of assists and goals is a madness but he doesn't carry Barca whatsoever
By urbanelite, in Music
Recommended Posts
3 totally different players tbh
lampard isnt realy a great central midfielder as his goals gloss over his actually ability in the centre of the park,
a very effective SS/AM tho
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nidge Weasle
yeah cause theres no way to watch premier league football unless you support a team in the league is there...
Link to comment
Share on other sites
anelka
bit of a myth thoe really
Lampard has a great engine, brilliant stamina, tactical awareness, can pass, scores goals and creates goals
if that isn't a recipe for a 'great central midfielder' then i don't know what is
Link to comment
Share on other sites
i5_PRODUCER
I'm saying Gerard , maybe the goals have dried up a little but he really is a jack of all trades .Lamps will get u the goals but defensively he will rarely track back.
But In a deep lying position carrick all day them through balls split defenses like crazy.
They all perform to the best of abilities in diff pos
Gerard Cm
Lamps am/ss
Carrick deep lying play maker
Link to comment
Share on other sites
mark_INIESTA_davies
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Thizz
A few years ago not now.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lieutenant
Stevie G
Link to comment
Share on other sites
stacksbranning
- technically - Carrick
- tactically - Dont know what you mean by this
- in possession - Carrick
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Posted