Given vs Harper

[Davicious X]

A few years ago it was widely agreed that Shay Given was considered one of the best keepers in the country, where did it all go wrong for him?I think he started slipping off around the time Rooney scored THAT goal but Im not too sure

[FamilyTree]

went down hill after his stomach acids started burning his other internal organstrue stories

[Guest F.O.S]

brambletaylorcapacaroznehalhappened and the rest

[Black.]

Both them keepers should have kicked time ago to better clubs

[Lieutenant]

what do you mean vs?theres no competition, when given is fit he will retain his no.1 spotlol @ steve harper playing 50 games in 10 years

[Guest Robin_Van_PersG]

Steve harpers one of the unluckiest/stupidest keepers ever. He's top notch just had Given who has been just as important as Shearer during his time at newcastle. Don't think givens fell off at all still arguably the best shotstopper in the league.

[HangTheDJ]

Given is still number 1It's just that Harewood slid into him 18 months ago and gave him "injuries similair to that of a serious car crash" and he's been unable to regain regular fitness since.