David Villa or Berbatov?

[The Infamous]

Villa is 10times the playerOne player is one of the best in the world while one has had a productive seasonNot even up for argument

[Rsonist]

Villa is 10times the playerOne player is one of the best in the world while one has had a productive seasonNot even up for argument

Of course its up for argument.You are going on like Villa is Maradona or Pele esk.He is good, but not a God.

[The Infamous]

David VillaClub: Sporting de Gijón- 80 (38) App (Gls)* Club: Real Zaragoza- 73 (31) App (Gls)* Club: Valencia-69 (38) App (Gls)* BerbatovClub: CSKA Sofia- 50 (25) App (Gls)*Club: Bayer Leverkusen- 152 (68) App (Gls)* Club: Tottenham Hotspur- 33 (12) App (Gls)*No contest at all one is one of the most feared strikers in the planet while Berba has scored against minnows such as Club Brugge and Besiktas.I think Villa would find this comparison offensive and so would the footballing world.Compare them next season if Barbatov does well again until then it is not a contest

[Gundam]

Berba got a better first touch still.I would like to see Villa in the prem, and see how he does in his first season.

[Rsonist]

So your basis of "Villa is 10x the player Berbatov is", is based soley on goals.How shallow you are....

[The Infamous]

He has vision and skill aswellSo does Berbatov It is a draw in that aspectSo it goes down to goalsThe 10times statement is a over reaction still

[BATTY BOY BUM BANDIT]

Villa is too much.Berbatov is sick, but not on David's level.

[Dizzle]

Haven't seen much of Villa but from what I know of him, him and Berbatov are not comparable as they about as different as strikers come...

true they aint that similarbut id have berbatovespecially as people r talkin about 25 mil for villa

I think their very similarThink about both there attributes & what they bring to a team & you'll see what Im saying.

[BATTY BOY BUM BANDIT]

Villa>>>>>>>God.

[The King]

villa would get bullied in the premier league

[Glock]

They are different players. If Berbatov can replicate this season next year then I'll comment. Man came to the prem and murked in his first season. Hopefully Villa will come to, then it'd be a fairer comparison.

[Guest roskie_07]

villa